How to follow up after no response: training sales reps to reopen a stalled deal
The demo went well, the proposal went out the next day, and the prospect has been silent for three weeks. To follow up after no response, the salesperson has to reopen the conversation without blame, find out what changed and leave with a dated next step, even if that step is ending the project.
- For
- Inside and field sales reps, account managers
- Duration
- 5 to 10 minutes per round
Three weeks without a reply.
Since the silence began, the rep has sent a first email, “Just following up on our proposal,” then a second, almost identical one a week later. Now they hesitate to call.
When they finally call, two mistakes come up. They point out the silence, even politely (“I haven't heard back from you”), and the prospect, already embarrassed, gets defensive and cuts the call short. Or they walk through the proposal line by line, sometimes adding a discount nobody asked for, without knowing whether the prospect's situation has changed.
The silence has a cause the rep doesn't know about: a budget freeze, someone leaving, another project taking priority, an in-house option pushed by a colleague. The same thing happens with existing customers who haven't ordered in months.
In short
The rep often calls back and either points out the silence or repeats the offer. A sales follow-up should first find out what changed for the prospect.
What research says.
In 2000, Willem Verbeke and Richard Bagozzi studied anxiety among 189 mortgage salespeople in two situations they found threatening, prospecting and closing. They define it as a persistent fear of being judged negatively and rejected by the customer, along with a desire to avoid certain selling actions. It also showed in protective behaviors, such as avoiding eye contact or saying as little as possible about oneself, and it weighed on the salespeople's results.
Calling a prospect who has stopped answering carries the same risk of hearing no, and sending a third email instead of calling looks a lot like the protective reactions they describe.
In the cold calls studied by Bogdana Humă and Elizabeth Stokoe, a prospect who wants neither to accept nor refuse a meeting proposes a slower next step: an email instead of a meeting, a call in a few months, a decision that depends on colleagues. A silence can start that way, and when the rep has accepted the stall without setting a date, the follow-up starts from further back. Our guide on writing a cold calling script shows how to answer a stall on the first call.
In short
Fear of rejection pushes salespeople to avoid certain selling actions, and it weighs on their results. A stall accepted without a date makes the follow-up harder.
The scenario to roleplay.
The rep calls and finally reaches the prospect, who hasn't prepared anything.
The prospect
- Who she is
- Helen Ross, HR director of a group of 25 car dealerships. Five weeks ago she attended a demo of performance review software, then received the proposal: $40,000 a year.
- What she says first
- “Oh, hi. Yes, I saw your messages, sorry. I haven't had a chance to present your proposal yet, other things came up.”
- What she keeps to herself
- The group just bought six more dealerships, and new projects are frozen until April. The IT director wants to use the HR module of their existing ERP. She prefers the rep's solution, but lacks arguments for the executive committee.
- What opens her up
- A question about what has changed since the demo, asked without blame, then something new: a phased rollout, a comparison with the existing module, onboarding the six new dealerships.
- What shuts her down
- A reminder of the silence, the proposal reread line by line, a discount offered upfront. She then ends with: “I'll get back to you once things are clearer.”
The salesperson
- What they know
- The demo, the proposal, the two unanswered emails. They don't know about the acquisition or the freeze.
- Their goal
- Find out what changed, then get a dated next step (a call with the IT director, a decision date) or a clear end to the project.
- Duration
- Five to ten minutes.
Variants change the situation: a prospect gone quiet after a demo, with no proposal yet; a customer who hasn't ordered in six months; a contact who left, whose successor doesn't know the deal. A fourth variant starts from a trade show contact who was never called back. Our sales roleplay scenarios include a short version to run among colleagues.
In short
The prospect has a reason for her silence, which she only shares if asked without blame. The rep has to find it and leave with a dated next step, or a clear stop.
The scoring rubric.
| Criterion | What to observe |
|---|---|
| Opening | The rep introduces themselves and recalls the last exchange in one sentence, without mentioning the silence |
| What changed | They ask what has happened since the demo before talking about the offer again |
| Listening | They rephrase the constraint (frozen projects, in-house option) and ask for details |
| Something new | They bring information, a case or an option the prospect hasn't heard yet |
| Concessions | No discount offered unprompted; something in return if one is granted |
| Next step | A dated step, or a clear stop with a date to reconnect |
Logged in the CRM with a date to reconnect, a clear stop keeps a deal that has stopped moving from sitting open for months.
Template to download: follow-up scenario sheet and scorecard
The trainer's sheet, with what the prospect keeps to herself and the variants, then the observer's scorecard with six criteria, as a two-page PDF.
In short
The rubric follows the call, from an opening without blame to the next step, including the question about what changed and the new element.
Practicing follow-ups in Engramm.
In an Engramm AI roleplay, you build the follow-up from your open deals: the prospect, the proposal sent, how long the silence has lasted and what lies behind it. The rep calls out loud, the prospect answers with her hesitations, and the scorecard follows the criteria in your rubric. After the call, the AI coach suggests other follow-up angles suited to that type of prospect.
Before calling back a prospect on a large deal, a rep can also rehearse the call the day before, on a scenario that recreates that specific case.
In short
In Engramm, the rep rehearses the follow-up on a scenario drawn from your deals, scored on your criteria, then goes over it with the AI coach.
Frequently asked questions.
How do you follow up with a prospect who doesn't respond?
Call rather than sending a third identical email. Recall the last exchange in one sentence without blaming them for the silence, ask what has changed, bring something new, then propose a dated next step. If the project is on hold, log it and agree on a date to reconnect.
How many times should you follow up with a prospect?
We found no published study that gives an ideal number. Set a shared rule for the team, for example three attempts across different channels, then a last message offering to close the file. Each follow-up should bring something new.
What should a follow-up email after no response say?
One sentence recalling the last exchange, something new for the prospect (information, a customer case, an option) and a simple question they can answer in one line. “Just checking in” tells them nothing.
Sources.
- Willem Verbeke and Richard P. Bagozzi (2000), “Sales call anxiety: Exploring what it means when fear rules a sales encounter,” Journal of Marketing, 64(3), 88-101: repub.eur.nl
- Bogdana Humă and Elizabeth Stokoe (2023), “Resistance in business-to-business ‘cold’ sales calls,” Journal of Language and Social Psychology, 42(5-6), 630-652: researchonline.lse.ac.uk


