AI coach or human coach: what each brings to training
AI coaches are spreading in companies, and the question comes up in every training project: can they replace a human coach? It depends on what you call coaching, because the word covers two very different jobs.
Two jobs behind the word coaching.
The first is one-on-one support. A coach helps an executive, a manager or an employee through a transition, a decision or a change in how they work. Sessions run over several months and rest on the relationship between the coach and the person being coached.
The second is skills practice. A trainer, a manager or a peer has someone rehearse a specific situation: a discovery call, a negotiation, an annual review, a customer complaint. They watch, give feedback, and have them start again.
Both go by the same name. The first rests on the relationship and the coach's judgment, the second on repetition and precise feedback at each attempt, and AI coaches add the most to the second.
In short
Coaching covers one-on-one support, based on the relationship, and skills practice, based on repetition. AI coaches add the most to the second.
What the studies say.
In 2022, Nicky Terblanche and colleagues published in PLOS ONE two randomized trials with the same protocol, run over ten months. In the first, participants were coached by human coaches; in the second, by a coaching chatbot. Each trial had its own control group.
On attaining the goals participants had set themselves, both the human coaches and the AI coach did significantly better than the control groups, and the AI coach did as well as the human coaches by the end of the trials. The authors are careful about the scope: the chatbot applied a structured goal-tracking approach, and they consider that AI's lack of empathy and emotional intelligence makes human coaches irreplaceable for now.
In 2025, Amber Barger published a study in Frontiers in Psychology on the working alliance, the relationship of trust between coach and coachee. During a one-hour session, participants were coached either by a human coach or by an avatar presented as an AI. Both groups described a comparable working alliance. One major limit: the “AI” was in fact operated by human coaches, without participants knowing. The study measures how participants perceive an AI coach; it says nothing about what an AI can do on its own.
Both studies concern one-on-one coaching. Neither looks at practicing conversation skills, where AI is used differently: it plays the other person, observes the exchange and evaluates it.
In short
In 2022, an AI coach matched human coaches on goal attainment. The published studies concern one-on-one coaching; none yet covers practicing conversations.
What an AI coach does well.
An AI coach is available, first of all. It answers at any hour, with no slot to book, the day before a meeting as well as between two calls. A salesperson can redo the same preparation or the same conversation ten times without tying anyone up, and every exchange is scored on the same criteria, whatever the team or country.
Set up on a topic and fed with the company's documents, it also knows the company's products, sales methods and procedures. A general-purpose assistant like ChatGPT or Copilot answers everything without knowing anything about the company, and gives managers no follow-up.
Engramm's AI coach works this way: one coach per topic, based on your documents, with three modes. Employees can prepare for a situation, recap what they learned after a training session, or explain a topic to the AI to check they've mastered it. A recap a few days after training comes when forgetting is fastest, as the forgetting curve shows.
In short
An AI coach gives each employee availability, repetition, the same scorecard for everyone and knowledge of the company.
What remains a human coach's job.
A human coach is still needed as soon as the situation goes beyond rehearsing a skill. A difficult new role, a conflict or a loss of confidence call for listening and a read of the context: a team's stakes, what doesn't get said in meetings, the history of a relationship. Moving from expert to manager, or from salesperson to key account manager, also takes time. And for an executive, being listened to by an experienced person matters in itself.
In training, this role often falls to trainers and managers. They design the programs, choose the situations to work on and support the complex cases.
In short
Sensitive situations, reading the context and changes of role remain the work of a human coach, a trainer or a manager.
The AI coach in sales and customer service training.
Conversation jobs are where practice matters most, and where it's most often missing: a sales manager rarely has time to have every rep rehearse every meeting. An AI coach steps in at three moments:
- Before a meeting, it helps prepare from the context given, anticipate the customer's objections and buying motives, and review the offer.
- During practice, the salesperson trains against a customer played by AI, in a simulation evaluated with a scorecard.
- Afterwards, they go over the improvement areas with the coach, and check their knowledge after a training session.
Agents in contact centers, medical reps and bank advisors follow the same pattern: prepare, practice, review.
In short
For a salesperson or an advisor, the AI coach steps in before the meeting, during practice and afterwards, to go over improvement areas.
Combining the two.
In most programs, the two split the work:
- the AI coach handles daily practice: preparation, repetition, review;
- scorecards and dashboards show, team by team, the weakest skills and the topics least worked on;
- trainers and managers spend their in-person time on those points, and the human coach on individual situations.
Trainers then spend their classroom time on what practice brought up, rather than having everyone rehearse the same situations.
| Task | AI coach | Trainer or manager | Human coach |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prepare a meeting, review an offer | Yes | ||
| Rehearse a conversation, with feedback at each attempt | Yes | ||
| Choose the situations to work on | Yes | ||
| Go over the team's weak points | Yes | ||
| Support a new role, a conflict | Yes |
In short
AI handles daily practice; trainers and managers work on the weak points that scorecards bring up.
Questions to ask before choosing an AI coach.
Before rolling out an AI coach to your teams, a few questions avoid bad surprises:
- Where is the data hosted, and in which region does the language model run?
- Are conversations used to train the models of the vendor or its suppliers?
- What does the manager see: the conversations themselves, or the topics worked on and the gaps? Employees should know before using it.
- What content does the coach rely on: your documents, or general knowledge?
- Which languages does it work in, for your subsidiaries and teams abroad?
- Does it integrate with your LMS and single sign-on?
For Engramm: the application is hosted in France, the language model runs in a France region and voice processing happens in Europe. No model is trained on customer data. The platform works in more than 70 languages and integrates with LMSs via SCORM or xAPI, with single sign-on.
Template to download: AI coach evaluation worksheet
What the coach should do for your teams and the six questions to ask the vendor, with one column per solution, as a one-page PDF.
In short
Before choosing an AI coach, check data hosting, whether conversations train models, what the manager sees, the languages and LMS integration.
Frequently asked questions.
Can an AI coach replace a human coach?
For skills practice, an AI coach takes on a large part of the work: preparation, repetition, evaluation. For one-on-one support, especially in sensitive situations or transitions, a human coach is still needed. The two combine: AI for daily practice, people for the cases that call for it.
Is an AI coach cheaper than a human coach?
They aren't billed the same way. A human coach is paid per session or per program, for a limited number of people. An AI coach is usually paid per user per month, and each employee can use it as much as they like. At Engramm, it's a subscription per learner per month, with no commitment, or annual at a reduced rate.
When should you use a human coach rather than an AI coach?
For a new role, a transition, a conflict, a personal situation, or whenever the team's context matters as much as the skill. To rehearse a meeting, a negotiation or a difficult call, an AI coach lets you practice as much as you need.
How does a manager follow the work done with an AI coach?
With Engramm, managers see on a dashboard who used the coach, on which topics, and which gaps were detected. They use it to choose what to go over with the team or in one-on-ones.
Sources.
- Nicky Terblanche, Joanna Molyn, Erik de Haan and Viktor O. Nilsson (2022), “Comparing artificial intelligence and human coaching goal attainment efficacy”, PLOS ONE: journals.plos.org
- Amber S. Barger (2025), “Artificial intelligence vs. human coaches: examining the development of working alliance in a single session”, Frontiers in Psychology: pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov


