Use case

How to respond to negative reviews: training your team on the public reply and the follow-up call

A one-star review stays online, and people who haven't bought anything yet will read it. Knowing how to respond to negative reviews takes two skills that customer service teams rarely practice before they need them: writing a few lines in public, then calling the customer to fix the problem. Both can be trained with the same scenario.

Behind her bakery counter, an owner reads a customer review on her phone before replying
Situation
A customer posts a one-star Google review after a failed delivery; the team replies in public, then calls her
For
Customer service agents, digital customer care staff, community managers and their managers
What's evaluated
The tone and content of the public reply, moving the conversation offline, then listening, checking the account and the solution during the call
In Engramm
AI roleplays, scorecard, AI coach, manager dashboard

A review your next customers will read.

Denise Walker ordered a couch from an online furniture retailer. It arrived with a broken leg, the replacement delivery was canceled twice, and the callback customer service promised never came. On a Sunday night, she posts this review on the retailer's Google Business Profile:

“Couch arrived damaged, replacement delivery canceled twice. Three calls to customer service, three different answers, and the callback I was promised within 48 hours never came. Would not recommend.”

The one-star review in the scenario

The agent who replies on Monday is also writing for everyone who will look at the profile before ordering. Some replies get defensive: they quote the delivery terms, hint that the customer wasn't home, mention her order number. Others offer a refund in public, which the next unhappy customers will ask for too.

Then comes the call, with a customer who is still angry, has read the reply and wants a delivery date.

In short

The public reply is read by future customers, then comes the call. Bad replies get defensive or promise compensation.

What research says about review responses.

In the hotel industry, where online reviews have been studied for a long time, Davide Proserpio and Georgios Zervas followed hotels in 2017 that started replying to reviews: their average rating went up by 0.12 stars and they received 12% more reviews. Negative reviews became fewer and longer because, according to the authors, a guest who knows the hotel will read the review avoids a short complaint they couldn't back up.

In 2018, Yang Wang and Alexander Chaudhry showed that a response to a negative review improves the ratings other customers post afterwards, more so when it addresses the specific points of the complaint. Responses to positive reviews have the opposite effect, more so when they repeat the guest's compliments: the hotel then seems to be using them as advertising.

50%of consumers surveyed are put off by generic or templated replies
81%expect a response to their review within a week

Both figures come from a 2026 survey of 1,002 US adults by BrightLocal, a review management software company.

As for the call, a 2007 meta-analysis by Celso de Matos and colleagues shows that a customer whose problem was handled well ends up, on average, more satisfied than before the incident, with no effect on repurchase intentions or word of mouth. None of these studies measures the effect of training a team.

In short

A specific response improves later ratings. A problem handled well leaves the customer more satisfied, with no measured effect on loyalty.

How to respond to negative reviews in public.

Google advises keeping replies short and polite, never revealing private information, being honest about mistakes and personalizing the reply. Two sample replies to Denise's review:

Defensive replyReply that sets up the call
“Hello, our deliveries are handled by a carrier partner, and our terms state that customers who miss a delivery must reschedule it themselves. Your order #48213 is being processed. Customer Care”“Hi Denise, we promised you a callback and it didn't happen. That's our mistake, and we apologize. I'm taking over your file and will call you today to set a delivery date. Kevin, Customer Care”

The second one names the fact the retailer is responsible for, says nothing about the order, offers no compensation and gives a name and a time frame for the call.

In short

The public reply is three sentences long and points to a call.

The roleplay scenario.

The agent first writes the public reply, then calls Denise, who has read it.

The public reply

Context
The review and the account history: a broken leg, two canceled deliveries, a callback promised within 48 hours that never happened.
Instructions
Write the reply posted on Google in ten minutes, following the company's review response guidelines.
Goal
Three or four sentences, with no personal details and no compensation offer, announcing the call.

The call

The customer
Denise Walker, 46, a customer for three years, still annoyed.
What she says first
“Oh, now you call. I had to post a review to get someone on the phone.”
What she keeps to herself
She never confirmed the time slot sent by text for the second delivery. She wants the couch before Saturday the 20th, her daughter's birthday, and will update her review if the date is kept.
The agent's goal
Let her tell her story, acknowledge the missed callback, go through the history with her without blaming her, then agree on a firm delivery date.

If she says she'll order elsewhere, our use case on a customer who wants to cancel takes it from there. The one on the frustrated omnichannel customer covers contacts that went unanswered.

In short

The customer keeps a share of responsibility and a deadline to herself, which the agent uncovers by asking questions.

The scorecard.

PartCriterionWhat to look for
ReplyFact acknowledgedThe missed callback is named, with no “sorry for any inconvenience”
ReplyPrivacyNo order number, no hint that she wasn't home
ReplyPromisesNo compensation offered in public
ReplyNext stepA first name, a channel and a time frame for the call
CallListeningThe customer speaks without being interrupted; paraphrasing before answering
CallCheckingThe history is reviewed with her before explaining the cancellations
CallSolutionA firm date, confirmed in writing, and a direct number
CallReviewNo request to update or remove the review

Paraphrasing is covered in our guide to active listening, and the call criteria match the quality scorecard used in call center agent training. Differences between agents also help you write review response guidelines with the communications team.

Template to download: negative review scenario sheet and scorecard

The trainer's scenario sheet, with the review, what the customer keeps to herself and a sample reply, then the scorecard for the reply and the call, as a two-page PDF.

In short

Four criteria for the public reply, four for the call.

The scenario in Engramm.

In Engramm, the call is played out loud, on a scenario built from your review response guidelines and procedures. The simulated customer knows the review and the reply that was posted, and responds in under 500 ms. After the call, the agent gets a scorecard based on your criteria, and the AI coach goes back over the moments when the conversation got tense. Variants change the customer's tone or where the review was posted, and the dashboard shows the manager which criteria are causing trouble. The same call center simulator covers other difficult calls. Delivering bad news or a delay to a customer is one of them.

In short

The call is played out loud with a simulated customer who has read the reply, and the scorecard uses your criteria.

Frequently asked questions.

How do you respond to a negative review?

Reply quickly, in a few sentences. Acknowledge the specific problem and apologize for what your company is responsible for, with no account details and no compensation offered in public. Offer a call or an email with a name and a time frame, then keep to it.

How do you respond to an unfair negative review?

Stick to the facts, without disputing how the customer felt or accusing them, for example: “We couldn't find an order under this name. Could you email our customer service team so we can look into it together?” If the review breaks Google's content policy, you can also flag it.

Can you delete a negative Google review?

A business can't delete a review posted on its Business Profile. It can flag the review if it breaks Google's content policy, and it can reply; the reply appears as coming from the business.

Sources.

  • Davide Proserpio and Georgios Zervas (2017), “Online Reputation Management: Estimating the Impact of Management Responses on Consumer Reviews”, Marketing Science, 36(5), 645-665: doi.org
  • Yang Wang and Alexander Chaudhry (2018), “When and How Managers' Responses to Online Reviews Affect Subsequent Reviews”, Journal of Marketing Research, 55(2), 163-177: doi.org
  • Celso Augusto de Matos, Jorge Luiz Henrique and Carlos Alberto Vargas Rossi (2007), “Service Recovery Paradox: A Meta-Analysis”, Journal of Service Research, 10(1), 60-77: doi.org
  • BrightLocal, “Local Consumer Review Survey 2026”, February 11, 2026, panel of 1,002 US adults: brightlocal.com
  • Google Business Profile Help, “Tips to get more reviews”, section “Tips to write better review replies”, accessed October 30, 2026: support.google.com
  • Google Business Profile Help, “Manage customer reviews”, accessed October 30, 2026: support.google.com

Geoffrey Mathern

Director of Operations, Engramm

Geoffrey Mathern has been Director of Operations at Engramm since October 2025. He works with the training teams and sales leaders of Engramm's customers, from scenario design to tracking results. Before Engramm, he spent more than ten years in digital marketing and SEO, including almost six at Fabernovel.

LinkedIn profile
Newsletter

Get the next resources.

An email every two weeks with new guides, customer stories and webinars.

See Engramm on one of your topics.

In 45 minutes, we show you the platform on a topic your teams work on.

Book a demo
Book a demo