Use case

How to deliver bad news to customers over the phone

A washer that will arrive twelve days late, a refund that's been denied: agents regularly have to deliver bad news to customers who were expecting something else. Many wrap it in so many precautions that the customer misunderstands or calls back. Delivering bad news can be practiced in simulation, on a call where the agent has to give the news in the first few sentences, provide a date and offer an alternative.

A customer service agent wearing a headset explains a delivery delay over the phone
Situation
The agent calls a customer to tell him his delivery is delayed
For
Customer service agents, account specialists and their supervisors
Length
A simulated call of about 5 minutes, to replay with other kinds of news
What's evaluated
How clearly the news is given, the date, the explanation, the customer's reaction, the options offered

Delivering bad news to customers.

Marcus Reed ordered a $549 washer from an appliance retailer's website, with delivery and installation on Thursday between 8 a.m. and noon, an option he paid $39 for. On Tuesday, the warehouse flags a stockout. The next possible delivery is in twelve days. The agent has to call him with the news before he finds out from an automated email.

The same kind of call applies to a denied refund or a rescheduled repair, with a customer who was expecting a different answer.

In short

An agent has to tell a customer his washer will arrive twelve days late. A denied refund or a rescheduled repair is delivered the same way.

What makes the news hard to deliver.

The agent knows Mr. Reed won't take the news well, and puts off saying it. The call opens with precautions (“I'm calling about your order, there's a small issue on our end”), and the delay only comes out after a minute. By then the customer has had time to worry without knowing what about.

The agent may also reassure him without grounds (“it should normally go faster than that”), and he will call back when the date slips. Some agents hide behind the rules (“that's our policy”), or announce the delay with nothing to offer instead. When the news comes out in a jumble, the customer concludes the company doesn't know where his order stands.

In short

The agent delays the news, buries it in precautions or reassures without grounds. With no date and no alternative, the customer calls back.

What research says.

In 2014, psychologists Angela Legg and Kate Sweeny, of the University of California, Riverside, ran three studies on delivering news that is partly good and partly bad. People receiving the news overwhelmingly wanted the bad part first, while people giving it tended to start with the good part. When the givers were asked to take the recipient's perspective, they switched to the order the recipient preferred.

In 1985, David Maister, a former Harvard Business School professor, laid out eight propositions on the psychology of waiting. Two apply to announcing a delay: uncertain waits feel longer than known, finite waits, and unexplained waits feel longer than explained ones. He gives the example of patients told the doctor will see them “soon,” who grow more anxious than patients told to expect a thirty-minute delay.

In a Corporate Executive Board study published in 2010 in Harvard Business Review, covering more than 75,000 customers, 24% of repeat calls stemmed from a disconnect with the rep. The customer didn't trust the information given, or didn't like the answer and felt the rep was hiding behind company policy. The authors cite lighting maker Osram Sylvania, which coached its reps to replace “We don't have that item in stock” with the date it would be available.

In short

Customers prefer to hear the bad news first, and a precise, explained delay is easier to live with than a vague wait.

The scenario to practice.

The agent calls Mr. Reed on Tuesday, two days before the scheduled date.

ElementIn the scenario
The customerMarcus Reed, a customer of the retailer for two years. A $549 washer, with delivery and installation in a set window, paid $39.
His historyOrder placed eight days ago, Thursday window confirmed by text. The model is out of stock for twelve days. The retailer can offer a similar model at the same price, delivered Saturday, or refund the $39 delivery fee.
What he says up frontHe picks up in a good mood: “Is this about Thursday? I'll be home from 8.”
What he keeps to himselfHis old washer broke down ten days ago, he has two young children, and he took Thursday off for the delivery. He only says so if the agent asks what the delay means for him.
The agent's goalGive the delay in the first two sentences, with the new date, explain the stockout in one sentence, ask what the delay means for him, then present the options and confirm his choice.

If the agent opens with precautions, the simulated customer cuts in (“There's a problem with my order, isn't there?”). If he hears “normally” or “barring any surprises,” he asks for a guarantee the agent can't give.

The scenario can be replayed with other news, such as a denied insurance claim or a price increase at renewal, covered in our use case on how to announce a price increase. It's one of the scenarios in our call center simulator, along with the retention call described in when a customer wants to cancel.

In short

The customer doesn't mention the day off or the broken washer. The agent has to ask before offering a solution.

The scorecard.

CriterionWhat to listen for
Delivering the newsThe bad news comes in the first two sentences, in plain words.
DateA specific date, or failing that, the day the customer will get one. No promise the agent can't keep.
ExplanationThe cause fits in one or two sentences, without falling back on “policy.”
Customer's reactionThe agent lets the customer react, acknowledges the inconvenience and doesn't play it down.
OptionsThe agent asks what the delay changes for the customer, then offers the options that fit.
Next stepsThe customer's choice is confirmed, along with how he'll be kept informed.

These criteria add to the QA scorecard described in our guide to call center agent training.

In Engramm, the training team imports its delay and refund procedures, and the assistant builds the simulated customer and how he reacts. After each call, the agent gets a score on each criterion and can ask the AI coach at what point the customer got annoyed. During a wave of delays, the supervisor can have the whole team run the scenario before the first live calls, then follow the results in the dashboard.

Template to download: bad news call scenario sheet and scorecard

The trainer's scenario sheet, with what the customer keeps to himself and the variants, then the observer's scorecard, as a two-page PDF.

In short

The scorecard rates the clarity of the news and the date first, then the explanation, the handling of the customer's reaction and the options offered.

Frequently asked questions.

How do you deliver bad news to a customer?

Say it at the start of the conversation, in plain words, with a specific date. Explain the cause in a sentence or two, let the customer react, then lay out what you can do instead.

Should you give the good news or the bad news first?

In Angela Legg and Kate Sweeny's studies, most people receiving news that was partly bad wanted the bad part first. In customer service, that means stating the problem right away, then the options.

How do you tell a customer their delivery is delayed?

Reach out before they find out on their own, give the new date and say in one sentence why the delivery is late. Ask what the delay changes for them, then offer a solution, such as a similar product available sooner or a refund of the delivery fee.

Sources.

  • Angela M. Legg and Kate Sweeny (2014), “Do You Want the Good News or the Bad News First? The Nature and Consequences of News Order Preferences”, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 40(3), 279-288: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
  • David H. Maister (1985), “The Psychology of Waiting Lines”, in John A. Czepiel, Michael R. Solomon and Carol F. Surprenant (eds.), The Service Encounter, Lexington Books: davidmaister.com
  • Matthew Dixon, Karen Freeman and Nicholas Toman (2010), “Stop Trying to Delight Your Customers”, Harvard Business Review, July-August 2010: hbr.org

Geoffrey Mathern

Director of Operations, Engramm

Geoffrey Mathern has been Director of Operations at Engramm since October 2025. He works with the training teams and sales leaders of Engramm's customers, from scenario design to tracking results. Before Engramm, he spent more than ten years in digital marketing and SEO, including almost six at Fabernovel.

LinkedIn profile
Newsletter

Get the next resources.

An email every two weeks with new guides, customer stories and webinars.

See Engramm on one of your topics.

In 45 minutes, we show you the platform on a topic your teams work on.

Book a demo
Book a demo