Consultative selling: what it is, B2B examples and the Challenger sales methodology
Consultative selling is an approach in which the rep starts from the customer's problem and recommends a solution, the way an advisor would. The rep diagnoses before proposing anything, and may advise against a purchase that wouldn't meet the need. The Challenger sales methodology, published in 2011, adds an insight the rep brings to the customer.
What consultative selling is.
In consultative selling, the rep acts as an advisor. They start by understanding the customer's situation and the problem they're trying to solve, then recommend a solution, which can be part of their offer, a different way of working, or nothing at all for now.
The term is associated with Consultative Selling, the book by Mack Hanan, James Cribbin and Herman Heiser published in 1970 by the American Management Association and reissued several times since. The closely related term “solution selling” is used when the rep sells a combination of products and services built around the customer.
The rep spends more time asking questions than presenting the offer, and only makes a proposal after checking with the customer that they have understood the problem correctly.
In short
The rep starts from the customer's problem, makes a diagnosis, then recommends the solution that addresses it, even if it's smaller than expected.
Consultative selling vs. transactional selling.
In a transactional sale, the customer knows what they want to buy and mostly compares price, lead time and terms. Restocking office supplies or adding lines to a business mobile plan are typical cases. The rep answers quickly, and a long diagnosis would annoy the customer.
The consultative selling approach fits the other case, a customer who knows their problem but not how to solve it. In a 2012 Harvard Business Review article, Brent Adamson, Matthew Dixon and Nick Toman explain that solution selling worked for decades for that reason: customers often understood their problems well but didn't know how to solve them on their own.
| Transactional selling | Consultative selling | |
|---|---|---|
| What the customer knows | What they want to buy | Their problem, rarely the solution |
| Where the rep starts | The product requested | The customer's situation and problem |
| Length | One call or meeting | Several meetings |
| What decides the sale | Price, lead time, availability | The quality of the diagnosis and recommendation |
| Example | Restocking consumables | Reducing breakage in shipping |
A supplier often handles routine orders transactionally, and switches to a consultative approach when a customer comes in with a new project or problem.
In short
Transactional selling suits a customer who knows what they want to buy. A consultative approach suits a customer who knows the problem but not the solution.
The steps of a consultative sale.
The example follows a packaging supplier who gets a call from the logistics director of an online cosmetics brand asking for a better price on shipping boxes.
Prepare
- What the rep does
- Reads what's public about the customer and their industry, and forms hypotheses about their problems. Our guide to discovery questions offers a template for this work.
- In the example
- On the brand's website, several customer reviews complain about bottles arriving broken.
Discover
- What the rep does
- Asks about the customer's situation, difficulties and their consequences before talking about the offer. The situation, problem and implication questions of SPIN selling are built for this step.
- In the example
- “How many packages come back damaged each month, and what does a reshipment cost you?” The logistics director has never run the numbers.
Restate the diagnosis
- What the rep does
- Sums up what they've understood and gets the customer to confirm it before any proposal. Active listening techniques such as paraphrasing help here.
- In the example
- “So if I've got this right, the price of the box matters less than the breakage on your two glass products. Is that it?”
Recommend
- What the rep does
- Proposes what addresses the diagnosis, and says what they don't recommend.
- In the example
- Custom inserts for the two glass products and the current boxes for the rest of the range, a smaller order than a full switch.
Measure with the customer
- What the rep does
- Agrees with the customer on how the result will be judged, using the customer's own data.
- In the example
- A one-month trial on shipments, comparing returns due to breakage before and after.
Template to download: consultative sales meeting worksheet
The five steps of the meeting with an example and room for your notes, the Challenger variant, and the scorecard for the roleplay exercise, as a two-page PDF.
In short
The rep prepares, runs discovery, gets the diagnosis confirmed, then recommends a solution whose results they measure with the customer.
When the rep advises against buying.
A CFO wants to replace her expense management software because it costs too much. By asking questions, the rep learns that the company is switching ERP systems in six months, and that most of the cost comes from manual checks. He advises her to wait for the migration, then choose a tool connected to the new system, and to get back in touch at that point.
Advising against a purchase has an immediate cost for the rep, who loses or delays a sale. In return, the customer knows the next recommendation won't be driven by a quarterly quota. A sale that doesn't solve the customer's problem often ends in complaints or a contract that isn't renewed, especially with a subscription.
The rep can also offer part of the solution, a limited trial or another step, and say so plainly: “For what you've described, I wouldn't recommend the full module.”
In short
A consultative rep advises against a purchase that wouldn't solve the customer's problem, and offers a smaller option or a different next step.
The Challenger sales methodology.
In 2008, with the recession, sales reps at member companies of CEB (Corporate Executive Board, now part of Gartner) were missing their targets by wide margins. Matthew Dixon and Brent Adamson, researchers at CEB, studied what the few reps still hitting theirs were doing. The result was The Challenger Sale, published by Portfolio in November 2011. According to the publisher, the book is based on a study of thousands of sales reps across several industries and countries. Neil Rackham, the author of SPIN Selling, wrote the foreword.
The authors sort reps into five profiles. All of them can deliver average performance, but only one, the Challenger, consistently delivers high performance. The book also calls classic relationship building a losing approach, especially for complex B2B solutions. Matthew Dixon adds that the profiles aren't mutually exclusive, since most reps have a bit of each, with one dominant.
| Profile | What sets it apart |
|---|---|
| Hard Worker | Relies on effort and the number of meetings |
| Relationship Builder | Cultivates the relationship and wants to stay on good terms with the customer |
| Lone Wolf | Follows their own instincts more than company rules |
| Reactive Problem Solver | Responds quickly and fixes every customer issue, especially after the sale |
| Challenger | Brings the customer a new insight, tailors it to the person in the room and holds their ground |
In a 2012 interview with CRM magazine, Dixon defines the Challenger by three abilities, usually summed up as “teach, tailor, take control.” The example follows a maintenance services company meeting the leadership of a food processing plant.
Teach
- What the rep does
- Opens the meeting with information the customer doesn't have and that affects their costs or revenue, before presenting their own company.
- In the example
- Using data from comparable plants, the rep shows that most unplanned line stoppages come from spare parts ordered in a rush.
Tailor
- What the rep does
- Presents the same insight from the angle of each person who weighs on the decision. To identify those people and their criteria, the MEDDPICC framework provides a scorecard.
- In the example
- The plant manager hears about line stoppages, the buyer about rush-order premiums, the CFO about cash tied up in inventory.
Take control
- What the rep does
- Holds their ground when the customer pushes back. If the customer disputes the insight, the rep walks through it step by step, and if they ask for a discount, the rep brings the conversation back to the expected savings. The guide to closing a sale goes back over price negotiation.
- In the example
- “Before we talk discounts, let's look at what your last three stoppages cost you.”
In short
The Challenger sales model, based on CEB research published in 2011, identifies five rep profiles. The Challenger brings the customer an insight, tailors it to each stakeholder and holds their ground.
Consultative selling or the Challenger sales model.
Both approaches start from the customer and their problems. They differ on when the rep steps in and on what the rep brings.
| Consultative selling | Challenger sales | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting point | The problem the customer describes | An insight the rep brings, sometimes about a problem the customer hadn't seen |
| The rep's role | Diagnose and recommend | Make the customer think, tailor, hold their ground |
| Typical customer | Knows the problem, not the solution | Thinks they know the solution, or sees no problem |
| Risk | Arriving after the customer has defined their solution | Putting the customer off, or offering a poorly supported insight |
In their Harvard Business Review article, Adamson, Dixon and Toman note that customers, helped by more sophisticated procurement teams and purchasing consultants, now define solutions for themselves. A rep who waits to be told the problem arrives once the requirements are already written. The Challenger approach proposes stepping in earlier, with an insight that changes how the customer sees the problem. A Challenger still runs a discovery before recommending anything.
In short
A consultative approach starts from the problem the customer describes. The Challenger approach steps in earlier, with an insight that can change how the customer sees that problem.
The limits of both approaches.
A consultative approach takes time, several meetings for a diagnosis, which only pays off for deals of a certain size. It also requires a rep who knows the customer's business, or the questions stay generic. And a customer can use the diagnosis to write a request for proposal and buy elsewhere. To limit that risk, the rep can charge for part of the diagnosis, or run it together with the customer's teams.
On the Challenger side, Matthew Dixon himself acknowledges that Challengers are opinionated and willing to debate, and that many companies find them hard to work with. He adds that in a simple, transactional environment, the Hard Worker is a better fit. Holding your ground can also slide into sales pressure. The insight brought to the customer has to rest on solid data, which takes preparation, often by marketing or the company's experts.
In short
A consultative diagnosis takes time and requires knowing the customer's business. The Challenger approach needs a solid insight and can turn into pressure when handled poorly.
Consultative selling examples in B2B.
In each of these situations, the customer comes in with a specific request.
| Industry | What the customer asks for | What the rep uncovers | What the rep recommends |
|---|---|---|---|
| Staffing | About twenty temporary workers for the year-end peak | Last year, some of the temps quit in the first week because nobody onboarded them | Fewer temps, hired earlier, with half a day of on-the-job training |
| Software | A cheaper expense management tool | The cost comes from manual checks, and an ERP switch is coming | Wait for the migration, then pick a tool connected to the new system |
| Consulting | Negotiation training for the sales team | Discounts come from quarterly targets that push reps to close fast | Review discount rules with finance, then train the team |
Consulting firms, where consultants defend their recommendations in front of an executive committee, sell their engagements this way.
In short
The recommendation follows from the cause of the problem, and it often departs from what the customer first asked for.
Practicing consultative selling in a roleplay.
A rep who knows the offer well wants to present it as soon as the customer mentions a need. It takes practice to ask two more questions before proposing anything. The exercise takes three people, including an observer.
- The trainer writes the customer brief. The customer comes in with a specific request, for example a quote for a product, while their problem calls for a different solution. The brief describes that problem, its cause, and what the customer will only say if asked.
- The rep runs a twenty-minute conversation. They have to restate the diagnosis, get it confirmed, then recommend, which may mean a smaller solution than the one requested.
- The customer accepts a recommendation that addresses the cause of their problem, and shuts down if the rep pitches the requested product without asking questions.
- For the Challenger variant, the rep gets a data sheet on the customer's industry. They have to open with an insight drawn from that data, then hold their ground when the customer asks for a discount.
- The observer fills in the scorecard, then the group runs it again with a different stakeholder, for example a CFO instead of a VP of operations.
| Criterion | What to observe |
|---|---|
| Discovery | Did the rep find the cause of the problem before proposing? |
| Diagnosis | Did they restate the problem and get the customer's agreement? |
| Recommendation | Does it address the cause, even if it departs from the request? |
| Insight (Challenger variant) | Is the opening grounded in the data sheet? |
| Price | Faced with a discount request, did the rep bring the conversation back to value? |
With colleagues playing the customer, everyone plays the brief their own way, and two runs are hard to compare. In an Engramm AI roleplay, the scenario sets the customer's opening request, the problem they only reveal when questioned, and how they react to a proposal that comes too early. It's built from your documents, such as product sheets and customer case studies, and the character answers in under 500 ms. Variants change the stakeholder, from the VP of operations to the buyer. The scorecard follows your criteria, and the AI coach goes back over the moment the rep proposed too soon.
In short
This approach is practiced with a customer who asks for the wrong solution, using a scorecard that checks the diagnosis, its confirmation and the recommendation.
Frequently asked questions.
What is consultative selling?
Consultative selling is an approach in which the rep starts from the customer's problem, makes a diagnosis and recommends the solution that addresses it, the way an advisor would. The rep may propose less than the customer asked for, or advise against a purchase.
What is the difference between consultative and transactional selling?
In a transactional sale, the customer knows what they want to buy and compares price and lead time. In a consultative sale, the customer knows the problem but not the solution, and the rep helps define it over several meetings.
What is the Challenger sales model?
It's the approach Matthew Dixon and Brent Adamson describe in The Challenger Sale (2011), based on CEB research covering thousands of sales reps. The Challenger brings the customer a new insight (teach), adapts it to each stakeholder (tailor) and holds their ground, including on price (take control).
What are the five Challenger sales profiles?
The Hard Worker, who relies on effort, the Relationship Builder, who cultivates the relationship, the Lone Wolf, who follows their instincts, the Reactive Problem Solver, who fixes customer issues, and the Challenger. According to the authors, the Challenger is the only one who consistently delivers high performance in complex sales.
Sources.
- Mack Hanan, James Cribbin and Herman Heiser, Consultative Selling, American Management Association, 1970, catalog record: openlibrary.org
- Brent Adamson, Matthew Dixon and Nick Toman, “The End of Solution Sales”, Harvard Business Review, July-August 2012: hbr.org
- Matthew Dixon and Brent Adamson, The Challenger Sale: Taking Control of the Customer Conversation, Portfolio, 2011, publisher's description: penguinrandomhouse.com
- Judith Aquino, “Turn Your Sales Reps Into Challengers”, interview with Matthew Dixon, CRM Magazine, January 2012: destinationcrm.com


